Being Out Of Time

Apparently, there’s a kerfluffle going on about whether Martin Heidegger’s philosophy should be shelved alongside Nazi history books and Mein Kampf. See, Heidegger was an ardent member of the Nazi party, and the argument is that his philosophy is Naziïsh, too, and Nazis are bad so his books shouldn’t be available without a warning label! Or something.

Tim Black at Spiked! does a great job of exploding that argument in this article, showing how the philosophy has no fascistic trend in it at all, and in fact lends itself more to left-wing, anti-modern thought. In my experience, Heidegger’s pretty difficult to explain in layman’s terms, but Black does an admirable job of portraying both Heidegger’s philosophy and the impact it had on 20th century thinkers.

What is “my experience,” you ask? Well, despite having virtually no background in philosophy, I studied Heidegger’s main book, Being And Time, for a semester at my wacky hippie-trippy progressive college. Our professor, Tsenay Serequeberhan (now at Morgan State), was late to class every single time, leading us to rename the course to Being On Time.

Given Heidegger’s dense prose (translated from German, the densest language known to man), my aforementioned inexperience, and our professor’s Eritrean accent, I did not have an easy time of things in that class. Still, Tsenay did his best to convey something of Heidegger’s philosophy to a novice like me. (He also told us at the outset that he didn’t want to discuss Heidegger’s role in the Nazi party, especially since Being and Time was published long before Hitler’s rise, and should stand on its own.)

In one of the more concrete (albeit limited) examples, Tsenay addressed Heidegger’s contention that animals do not have emotions. “Here, I disagree with him,” he said. “You see, I believe animals have strong emotions. However, Heidegger is right to say that animals are not people, not da-sein; that is because they do not possess anxiety, the awareness of being-toward-death.

“When I was a Ph.D. student at Boston College, I had a little cat in my apartment. Every morning when I headed out to class, he would follow me out the door and down the street for a while. But every Tuesday, the garbage men would be outside with their bigbig trucks! And my cat would hear them and runbackinside as fast as she could.

“So, you see, when she runs from the garbage men, here the cat is demonstrating fear. But she is not evincing anxiety. If she were, then she would be sitting up every Monday night, worrying about the garbage men!”

For the rest of the session, I envisioned a housecat chewing away on its claws all night. I was not exactly living up to my utmost potentiality for being.

Just kidding: see, utmost potentiality for being is actually Heidegger-code for death! Now you’ve learned something! So go read Tim Black’s article already!

(Bonus Tsenay anecdote! He and I talked about Israel’s airlift of Jews out of Eritrea following the civil war there. I marveled over the concept of taking all the seats out of a 747 and jamming as many people as possible in per flight. He said, “They don’t understand, the Israelis. Eritrea is not Europe. In Africa, we do not have a revolution and then decide to kill all the Jews.” He had a way with words.)

Slow Fast

Every year on Yom Kippur, my dad & I make our annual trip to temple so he can recite Yizkor, the prayer for the souls of his dead parents. You can find my past writeups about this experience here (5768 edition) and here (5769). I was ready to continue this tradition on Monday morning, when I got a phone call from Dad around 8:30 a.m. (as should be abundantly clear by the fact that we go out to pray once a year, we’re not so observant that we won’t use the phone during a major holiday).

He’d pulled a muscle in his back on Sunday, and was laid out. I told him I was heading to shul around 11:00 a.m., and would call to see if he was feeling well enough for me to pick him up by then. He said, “If not, I need you to pray for my parents for me.”

“Sure thing, Dad,” I said. Then I thought, “Is that even allowed? I thought Yizkor was for the souls of immediate family! The rabbi always leaves the room before Yizkor because he’s ‘blessed to have both parents living.’ Is Dad trying to pull a fast one on God?” Considering my dad once took flowers from someone’s grave and put them on the underattended grave of his pal, I wouldn’t put it past him.

I decided not to think about this too much, mainly because the lack of caffeine was already crippling my higher brain functions. This summer, I managed to step down my caffeine use, but the month of September was pretty stressful and I really backslid in the last few weeks, setting myself up for a rough day of fasting.

Which is what it’s there for, y’know? We don’t fast on Yom Kippur so we can lose weight; we fast to afflict ourselves before God. The downside of this is that the only time I meet Rabbi Zvi, I’m a thick-tongued, headache-plagued wreck.

I called Dad at 11, but he was still immobilized by his muscle-pull. Even though I forgot to grab my yarmulke and my tallis before heading out, I at least had the presence of mind to ask him for the Hebrew names of his parents, so the rabbi could add them to his prayer. I also remembered to go without a belt and to wear canvas shoes, since we’re not supposed to wear leather or any other animal skin on the holiday. This led to my new fashion trend of suit-with-solid-black-Chuck-Taylors; it’ll be the next hot look.

This year, services were being held at a hotel, instead of the rabbi’s basement. It was only when I walked into the anteroom that I realized I’d forgotten my things. I looked around for the table with spare yarmulkes & tallises, but didn’t see one. The women and kids looked back at me from their partitioned area of the room, but didn’t offer any suggestions. Eventually, one of the men noticed me and gestured to a congregant along the back wall of the main room. He had been blocking my view of the phylactery table. He picked up a basket of yarmulkes and told me, “Pick a color! Any color!” I grabbed a light-blue suede kippah, a not-so-clean tallis, and a prayerbook. Another congregant pointed and said, “There’s an aisle seat in the second row,” so I took it.

Rabbi Zvi came right over and said, “Gil! Great to see you!” Last year, I was impressed that he remembered my name after a 1-year absence. This time, I was kinda embarrassed, since he’d e-mailed several times last spring to invite me & Amy over for shabbat dinner and Something Always Came Up. I told him about Dad’s plight, and he replied, “Well, at least you made it. We need you to put the cover on the Torah!”

One of the congregants was just finishing his aliyah. When the prayer was complete, he and the rabbi rolled the scroll back up. Then he lifted it, sat down in the front row, and my job began. All I had to do was put a binder around the Torah, put a cover over it, and hang its silver pointer from one of its handles. As I began to put the binder around it, the holder said, “Not so high.” I moved the binder all the way to the bottom and began to affix it. “Not so low,” he said. I went halfway. He said, “It should be around the top of the bottom third. If you can figure that out, you’re a real Jew!”

I did my best.

A few more prayers followed, then Rabbi Zvi announced the schedule for the rest of the day. He explained that we were a little behind, so he’d make up the time by cutting the breaks short. This is known as Yom Kippur humor. He told us that he wanted to give the full speech/lecture/sermon he had planned, but he had a cold and wasn’t feeling well, so he’d try to keep it short.

The first part of his sermon was about his experiences at the Lubavitcher high holiday services, which blended into an anecdote about Bibi Netanyahu c.1984 and the Rebbe Schneerson’s opinion that the U.N. was a house of lies. It wasn’t too politicized a speech, although I’m sure that wouldn’t have offended anyone in the congregation.

Then Rabbi Zvi told a story of Maimonides. Some rabbis were arguing (imagine!) about what it means to be human. One of them decided to train a cat to be a waiter, to show that animals could act just like us. So he trains the cat to wait tables, and the cat does a wonderful job of taking orders, bringing out plates, handling bills, etc. Then one of the rabbis lets a mouse free in the restaurant. The cat sees it, drops his plates and takes off to eat the mouse.

“Some of us,” he said (in paraphrase), “only come to services once a year. We take this day to atone to God for our sins. For one day, we fast and ask for forgiveness. But what about the other 364 days? Who are we on those days?” Our sins and temptations are our mice, he said. Which raised the question of whether our mice reveal our true nature. Are we hiding ourselves behind once-a-year piousness? Do studying Torah and fulfilling the mitzvot help us shed our cat-nature and become more human?

Naturally, I felt like Rabbi Zvi was looking directly at me when he talked about once-a-year congregants. I don’t feel too much guilt over this. I know I’m not living a Torah-directed life, but I also believe I’m living a good life. I try to help others in need, try to learn every day, try to improve on my bad habits (I’m back to a small mug of coffee this morning), try to laugh. Do I flip out in a rage at other drivers? Sometimes, but never to the point of cutting someone off to prove a point. Do I brood way too far? Sometimes, but then I’ll hear a Sam Cooke song or a see a pair of clouds that look just like Groucho Marx’s eyebrows, and my heart will lighten. Do I sin? Sometimes, but I’m also filled with love.

True to his word, the rabbi finished his sermon early. I prayed for the peace of my grandparents’ souls, stuck around for another 45 minutes, then headed home when a few other congregants started to disperse for a few hours. Despite my cloudy vise of a headache, I fasted through the 25-hour mark, then ate 6 slices of a pie from my favorite pizzeria, along with 3 glasses of water. I also had half a glass of Amy’s iced tea in order to alleviate my caffeine withdrawal but not keep me up all night. Oh, and Dad was feeling a little better by evening, but it was for the best that he stayed home.

What It Is: 9/28/09

What I’m reading: The new issue of Fantastic Man. Because I’m a fantastic man.

What I’m listening to: Essential Michael Jackson.

What I’m watching: A bunch of NFL, and The Rachel Zoe Project, which remarkably didn’t make me feel appreciably dumber. I guess it’s partly because, outside of the silly reality-show dramafication, the show also contains enough of the day-to-day aspects of Zoe’s job to be a little informative.

What I’m drinking: Red wine, although I don’t recall any of the labels. I didn’t drink too much during the conference-evenings, which is good. We took out a bunch of our event sponsors on Thursday night, and I managed to keep it down to 1.25 G&Ts, because our restaurant only had Tanqueray Ten on hand.

What Rufus is up to: According to my wife, he was pining for me while I was away at the conference. Thursday was the first time we used a dog-walker since Rufus got attacked last May. My brother took him outside once when he was here in July, but otherwise, it’s been me and/or Amy every day for 4+ months. Ru & the walker were fine.

Where I’m going: Nowhere, but my pals Ian & Jess are coming in for an overnight on Friday; we’re planning to take ’em to one of our favorite restaurants before seeing them on their way bright and early Saturday morning.

What I’m happy about: Our conference went off without a hitch! It just goes to show you what four micro-managing control freaks can accomplish when they all pull together! (Also, Crumb’s Book of Genesis is supposed to show up at my door sometime today! I’ll have some post-Yom Kippur reading that’ll actually be kinda Jew-y!)

What I’m sad about: Bill Safire died. And I’ve already started thinking about the speaker lineup for next year’s conference.

What I’m worried about: One of my speakers won’t show up.

What I’m pondering: Whether my body will manage to mistake nicotine (in the form of Ozona snuff) for the caffeine that I’m doing without for my Yom Kippur fast. I doubt it, but that’s why it’s a day of afflictions.

What It Is: 8/17/09

What I’m reading: Moby Dick, The Jew of New York, The Nobody, and Everybody is Stupid Except for Me.

What I’m listening to: Arular, by M.I.A., Yes by Pet Shop Boys, and Welcome to the Pleasuredome by Frankie Goes to Hollywood (thanks to their roof-raising performance in that Trevor Horn tribute concert we watched last week).

What I’m watching: Old episodes of The State, to commemorate the cancellation of Reno 911!, Anchorman and Pulp Fiction. Our current Netflix discs are The Man Who Would Be King and Bubba Ho-Tep.

What I’m drinking: Juniper Green & Q Tonic, and Red Stripe lager.

What Rufus is up to: Staying out of the heat. We skipped another Sunday greyhound hike because we had a bunch of Amy’s friends coming over for lunch that day, and needed to get the house clean(ish).

Where I’m going: Connecticut next weekend, to visit my cousins and let Rufus meet the Golden Retriever side of the family.

What I’m happy about: That someone made a movie for the 9-year-old me who was serenaded daily on the school bus with taunts of “Heil Hitler!”

What I’m sad about: This whole aging process.

What I’m worried about: The dietary habits of yuppies, and whether it stunts their ability to have intelligent conversation. (Good job, Agitator!)

What I’m pondering: Whether Smokey Bear is a gay icon.

Heavy-Duty Yarmulke

One of my pals from high school just e-mailed to tell me that she found her mailbox crushed in this morning, with this motorcycle helmet lying nearby:

jewhat

She asked if I would translate the text, which looks like a slightly miswritten YHWH to me.

There’s only one conclusion I can draw: there’s a hasidic biker gang on the prowl in Poughkeepsie! Lock up your children!

Except on Friday night, of course.